REVIEW: Beyoncé suffers from identity crisis on new album
2 and a half out of 5 stars
Stephen Ortiz
Issue date: 11/13/08 Section: Focus
If you've been near a radio in the past month, you probably have heard both of Beyoncé's new, split-personality singles. The first, "If I Were A Boy," is a slowed-down contemplation on how life would be if she had the chance to see through the eyes of a man. The second, "Single Ladies (Put A Ring On It)," is a bouncing, repetitive club jam for, well, the single ladies. So what's with the indecisiveness on a direction? Why, it's all part of Beyonce's new, schizophrenic album "I Am … Sasha Fierce."
So who exactly is Sasha Fierce? Who knows? This album is every bit Beyoncé as her past work, except instead of mashing all the passionate ballads with the club bangers, they're divided amongst two discs. Don't be mistaken, though - unlike Nelly's "Sweat/Suit" and Outkast's "Speakerboxxx/The Love Below" full double-albums, "I Am … Sasha Fierce" has designated R&B and pop discs but with six and five songs, respectively.
Much like vastly different lead singles, the two discs are complete opposites and not in a good way. Beyoncé has a beautiful voice - it's a well-known fact - so when she uses it properly, it's almost angelic, and she succeeds with flying colors. In the past, Beyoncé had proven herself to be capable enough to deliver dance-pop hits, but sadly this is not the case on "Sasha Fierce."
Besides the addictive "Single Ladies," the dance songs fall flat and are often lame. On "Radio," a techno, synth-heavy track, Beyoncé reveals her love affair with her radio because "it never lets her down." One section of the song finds her pronouncing her words like a knock-off version of Rihanna's "Umbrella," like when she sings, "When I get into my car, I turn it u-uh u-up / Then I hear vibrations all up in my tru-uh tru-unk."
Even worse is the abysmal "Diva," on which Beyoncé declares that a diva is a "female version of a hustler" over a deep bass-driven beat.
Luckily, "I Am … Sasha Fierce" is saved (but barely) by its ballads, most notably, the often-replicated "Ave Maria," which is Latin for "Hail Mary." The song is gorgeous; there's really no other way to describe it. Backed by a simple acoustic and piano melody, Beyoncé's voice soars in a way that it never has before.
"Halo" employs a combination of piano, synths and claps that makes for an uplifting song about finding that special someone, but can even be interpreted in the religion sense.
Beyoncé sings, "I found a way to let you in / But I never really had a doubt / Standing in the light of your halo / I got my angel now."
Beyonce has spent the last year working on "I Am … Sasha Fierce," but sadly the effort doesn't show. Instead of the emotional concept album she was aiming for, the end result turned out to be a muddled, half-decent attempt at much of the same.
So who exactly is Sasha Fierce? Who knows? This album is every bit Beyoncé as her past work, except instead of mashing all the passionate ballads with the club bangers, they're divided amongst two discs. Don't be mistaken, though - unlike Nelly's "Sweat/Suit" and Outkast's "Speakerboxxx/The Love Below" full double-albums, "I Am … Sasha Fierce" has designated R&B and pop discs but with six and five songs, respectively.
Much like vastly different lead singles, the two discs are complete opposites and not in a good way. Beyoncé has a beautiful voice - it's a well-known fact - so when she uses it properly, it's almost angelic, and she succeeds with flying colors. In the past, Beyoncé had proven herself to be capable enough to deliver dance-pop hits, but sadly this is not the case on "Sasha Fierce."
Besides the addictive "Single Ladies," the dance songs fall flat and are often lame. On "Radio," a techno, synth-heavy track, Beyoncé reveals her love affair with her radio because "it never lets her down." One section of the song finds her pronouncing her words like a knock-off version of Rihanna's "Umbrella," like when she sings, "When I get into my car, I turn it u-uh u-up / Then I hear vibrations all up in my tru-uh tru-unk."
Even worse is the abysmal "Diva," on which Beyoncé declares that a diva is a "female version of a hustler" over a deep bass-driven beat.
Luckily, "I Am … Sasha Fierce" is saved (but barely) by its ballads, most notably, the often-replicated "Ave Maria," which is Latin for "Hail Mary." The song is gorgeous; there's really no other way to describe it. Backed by a simple acoustic and piano melody, Beyoncé's voice soars in a way that it never has before.
"Halo" employs a combination of piano, synths and claps that makes for an uplifting song about finding that special someone, but can even be interpreted in the religion sense.
Beyoncé sings, "I found a way to let you in / But I never really had a doubt / Standing in the light of your halo / I got my angel now."
Beyonce has spent the last year working on "I Am … Sasha Fierce," but sadly the effort doesn't show. Instead of the emotional concept album she was aiming for, the end result turned out to be a muddled, half-decent attempt at much of the same.
Spring Break
Viewing Comments 1 - 10 of 13
sit01
posted 11/13/08 @ 8:47 AM EST
i think that she did a lot of progress ill buy this album cuz even if you say that I am sasha fierce is going to be great
love
posted 11/13/08 @ 9:27 AM EST
What the hell, two stars. I agree this album down plays Beyonce's true talent vs B'Day but hell B'day couldn't get enough airplay because it was too agresso-RB soul and so now she put out an album like Fergie and Rihanna and she gets 1/2 credit. (Continued…)
bob john
posted 11/13/08 @ 10:45 PM EST
the reviewer voted for mccain. people aren't ready for change.
Missy
posted 11/19/08 @ 9:50 PM EST
I agree with them on the album. I love Beyonce but I was very dissapointed with this album. She tried to go too European. She tried to use a alter ego to hide behind versus saying she feels the way she does AND Diva does sound like she stole that straight from Lil Wayne and some songs are like Rihanna. (Continued…)
Julia
posted 11/20/08 @ 11:05 PM EST
This review is ridiculous.
This is one of my favorite albums I own..
Shanta'
posted 11/21/08 @ 4:25 PM EST
I'm very disappointed in this album. There are only 2 good songs, maybe three. She has such a beautiful voice and it barely shows.
Business Opportunities
posted 11/22/08 @ 2:08 AM EST
Part of being a creative person is trying out things that do not work. People who are not successful yet cannot do this, but Beyonce can afford to do this. (Continued…)
Sharhonda from VA
posted 11/23/08 @ 3:06 PM EST
I love Beyonce but i will admit her first album was the best I am Sasha Fierce i was a little disappointed but only with the sasha fierce side i love the slow I am. (Continued…)
Mrs. Miller
posted 11/24/08 @ 4:24 PM EST
I love beyonce and I think she is a truly talented artist. Her first album "Dangerously in Love" was a wonderful ablbum and would have been hard to top. (Continued…)
Shan
posted 11/25/08 @ 1:31 PM EST
I am a true Beyonce fan and have to admit - I was disappointed of her new CD. I think she should of took more time off and went a different way with the new CD. (Continued…)
Post a Comment