Professors need to respect First Amendment rights
Our Opinion
Issue date: 3/4/09 Section: Commentary
|
John Wahlberg was in Paula Anderson's introductory public speaking class when the students received an assignment to make a presentation about a "relevant issue in the media." Given the fierce debate about whether or not students and professors should be allowed to carry weapons on campus - ignited by the fatal shootings at Virginia Tech - Wahlberg thought that concealed carry was an appropriate topic for class. It is important to note that while Wahlberg is a gun owner and a Second Amendment advocate, he never threatened to harm anyone during his presentation.
After giving the presentation - during which he advocated for students' right to bear arms - Wahlberg went to work, where he was told that he needed to go to the police station. At the station, officers questioned him about how many guns he owned and where he kept them.
This is just absurd. A student expresses his views about the Second Amendment under his First Amendment rights and is sent to the police for questioning because of it? It is also important to note that students did not complain about Wahlberg's presentation; the only person who reported feeling uncomfortable was the professor.
The scariest thing about all of this is that Anderson claims to have acted after receiving guidance and consultation from her department chair and the dean of her department. One would hope that someone in a position of power would see the absurdity of Anderson's reaction, but clearly that was not the case at CCSU.
Colleges are supposed to be refuges of learning and a place where controversial ideas can be aired. There is no justification for a professor to call the police on a student who gives a presentation that she doesn't agree with. That's not freedom of speech; that's the freedom to freely speak about subjects approved by the authorities. That's the sort of "freedom" that citizens of the Soviet Union, Nazi Germany, and Saddam's Iraq had. On a college campus - especially here in liberal New England - students should be allowed to express their opinions without fear of reprisals from their professors and the police.
Spring Break

Viewing Comments 1 - 10 of 13
Tammy Butonr
posted 3/04/09 @ 3:26 PM EST
Completely agree. I wonder if Prof. Anderson would have called the cops he Mr. Wahlberg had advocated legalizing marijuana. He certainly wouldn't have been called to the police station to be asked where he keeps his pot. (Continued…)
JefeinCA
posted 3/04/09 @ 3:46 PM EST
I am somewhat chagrined by the view that some constitutional rights are optional based on one's opinions. If one has an unpopular opinion (in the professor's view) it is seen as threatening. (Continued…)
clayton
posted 3/04/09 @ 4:11 PM EST
Just pathetic, this woman needs to be fired immediately. She should also be sued. What a pathetic disgrace that she's aloud to teach on a university campus. (Continued…)
UofU Student
posted 3/04/09 @ 5:21 PM EST
By now, you should all know that freedom of speech is only valid when the speech is politically correct. If he were alive, Neville Chamberlain would tell you that it's always best to give in to whatever the powerful want in order to avoid conflict. (Continued…)
Cristian Alexander
posted 3/04/09 @ 6:01 PM EST
Fire that teacher. She violated his rights and wasted tax payer money. She also falsely accused the student of being a threat. The only threat was to her intelligence. (Continued…)
Josue
posted 3/04/09 @ 6:50 PM EST
I love how people are turning this into a liberal vs. conservative argument, even when it's not warranted. It's like the conservatives still can't get over the fact the GOP lost the election and that conservatives are increasingly becoming more and more irrelevant. (Continued…)
Olney
posted 3/04/09 @ 10:59 PM EST
Just Heard this article on the NRA's news radio Sirius Patriot 144 Cam and Company. outstanding.
CSA
posted 3/05/09 @ 8:01 AM EST
Velcome to zee USSA comerade.
Phillybill
posted 3/05/09 @ 9:12 AM EST
If the University has a grievance system, the student should file a complaint re the Prof making him "uncomfortable by discouraging his exercise of the First Amendment. (Continued…)
LinuxGunOwner
posted 3/11/09 @ 5:18 PM EST
All this liberal anti-anything rhetoric is getting a bit much. Why is is when there is a pile o'shyte being stirred up there is a liberal with their hands on the spatula? And threat? What threat did this student make or pose? All that was done is an opposing point of view was verbalized and for that the student is given the 3rd degree?
Sorry but had I been the student I would have sued for slander and anything else a good lawyer could come up with. (Continued…)
Post a Comment